Tonight: Brainstorm possible ideas for the project below. Think about who you might work with.

Draft Assignment 

Wesley 3AP Social Issue Research and AP Synthesis Project:

Creating an AP Synthesis Prompt, Source Packet, and Paper

 “Come in to your research in ignorance, as long as you don’t come out that way.” 

Katherine Boo, author of the book, Behind the Beautiful Forevers: Life, Death, and Hope in a Mumbai Undercity, winner of the National Book Award,

Point Value: 200 points total

(100 points for synthesis prompt and materials; 70 points for student essay response; 20 points for hitting due-dates, etc.)

Assignment Background:   As we have just finished The Great Gatsby and anticipate reading Beloved, and prepare to take the AP Language and Composition exam, this project merges three topics of pertinent study: social problems, research, and synthesis essay writing.  The book is a springboard for talking about complex challenges in a complex world. But we also need to start preparing for the AP Language and Composition exam’s synthesis essay.  This project will help us hone our research skills, become more aware of a current social issues, consider possible solutions, and prepare for and practice writing a synthesis essay.

Assignment

Congratulations! The national AP test writers have nominated this class to write their next synthesis prompts. Yessss!!!!

Will I be given an example? Abso-freakin-lutely! While writing, use the AP packets (both the source packet and the student essay packets) to help guide you. These are your models!

Can I work with a partner? You betcha! You may work with a partner (of course you don’t have to…some people work better alone).

What do we do?                    

1)     Identify a current (in the news in the last two years), important, and debatable state, national or international issue.  Your issue must meet all of these criteria.

2)     Research that issue, problem, challenge.

3)     Develop a writing prompt/question that is debatable and offers an opportunity for a variety of responses.  You will need to write a prompt which invites the reader to consider at least two possible views of how to best deal with/improve the problem a

4)     Research – and select - a balanced mix of source documents which address the issue from different perspectives, thereby providing material to help foster a fair and balanced debate about possible responses or solutions.

5)     You will write your own summary and analysis of each of your sources, providing some perspective on why you chose them and how they support one response or another (e.g., pro vs con) to the prompt. Doing this summary and analysis of each source will help you later when you write an essay response to your own prompt.

6)     Write a synthesis essay in response to your prompt.

Intellectual Honesty:  I am aware that many of you have done research projects in the past, (e.g., last year in Global Studies), or are currently doing one for another class. That’s great. But I must stress that with this project I want you to research something new, not simply repackage another research project. Your topic must be a new for you and your partner. So, to be clear…you may not recycle, reuse other research projects (or parts of other projects). Learn something new – it’s good for you.

Also, although you might end up asking a question or writing a prompt that is similar to one found on a current events and/or debate-centered site like the New York Times Room for Debate page, you must find original source documents (and read them and extract excerpts from them)   You may not simply repackage debates and sources from other sources or from students in other classes. That is plagiarism. So while you may consult and use source materials from a variety of places, your questions and sources must not be plagiarized from sites that are doing something very similar to what I am asking you to do in this project.  Those sites might inspire you, make you aware of current issues and debates, but you are not allowed to simply use their exact prompt or all of their source materials (that would be plagiarism). I will, however, allow you to use a total of one source from a debate-centered site/book.

Topics that are not eligible for this project because they have been done too often (these leapt to mind)

Abortion

Gun control

Legalization of marijuana

Should schools require PE

Should schools provide free breakfast/lunch

Note: All topics/prompts are subject to approval by Mr. Wesley.

How to get started:

Brainstorm with people you know regarding complex, compelling issues/problems that exist in our state, nation or world.  What conflicts and challenges are out there now or looming in the future? What have you seen in the news? What have you talked about in classes (e.g., when we read 1984)? What have you discussed with family and friends?

Consult a variety of news sites and magazines to see what is being discussed and debated.  The following is a mix of centrist, conservative and liberal sources (in no particular order) which might help you get started. This is a good list, but only a partial list; there are many more out there: New York Times, Wall Street Journal, CNN, Fox News, PBS Frontline, BBC, The Guardian, Slate, The National Review, Mother Jones, The Economist, Popular Science, National Geographic, The Week, Slate, Huffington Post, Reason. Key question to begin your research:

Check out sites that special in social justice issues such as United Nations (UN) website (issues/campaigns), HumanRights.org, Amnesty International and Doctors Without Borders, to name a few.

Questions to help your explore your issue further…Who, What, Where, When, Why? The following questions will help you find important background.

Who is being effected by this issue?

What are the major reasons that this issue/conflict exists?

Where is this issue or conflict happening?

When did this issue or conflict begin?

What solution(s) might exist and what information needs to be considered in assessing which is best and/or practical?

Step one: You choose the topic (example—Syrian refugees).

Step two: This topic is too generic, but it is a great starting point.  Once you have the topic, begin to create a specific angle that leads to a clear question (this may take some research and searching)-examples:  Who are the Syrian refugees?  Why are they refugees? Why are they leaving Syria? Where are they going? What, if anything, should be done to help them? Who should help them? How can they be helped?

Step three: Formulate a guiding question—make sure that it is clear and specific— which could be turned into a synthesis prompt. A suitable question might be “Should the United States take in Syrian refugees, and if so, how many?” Note that you many AP prompts ask students respond to a statement or position, so you might choose to change your AP prompt into a debatable statement rather than a question. Bottom line: Your prompt must invite a student to take a position in the debate (e.g., the essayist might choose a pro or con position on accepting Syrian refugees)—but you, as the writer of the prompt, should attempt to remain neutral and be fair and balanced in framing the issue.

Step four: Find six sources which present balanced mix of source materials for the reader/writer to consider. For example, if you have a pro/con type of question/prompt, three sources should more clearly support one side of the argument (pro) while three other sources should more clearly support the other side of the argument (con); however, you may also include up to two sources which are neutral/objective. Also, remember that one of your six sources must be a visual source.  What is important is that overall your mix of sources provide balanced support for BOTH sides of the issue, not weak sources for one side and strong for the other.  Also, remember what I said about using sources from debate-centered sites: you may only use one source from that type of website (or book).

Source write-ups: Once you have selected your six sources, you must do a clear and concise paragraph write up on each source.  Explain which position (pro, con, objective) you believe the source best supports and why. These write-ups should be clear and concise: a well-developed paragraph which immediately states whether the source is best described as pro, con, or neutral, and then uses embedded quotes, paraphrase, and sound reasoning to explain why your team believes it best fits the pro, con, or neutral category.

IMPORTANT POINT: Your sources should be non-fiction, however, you have the option to replace one (but no more than one) of your written non-fiction pieces with an excerpt from a piece of fiction (e.g., 1984) we have read this year.

Also, please be sure to label each source as source A-F.  This label should be at the top of the page.

Finally, create an AP style rubric (1-9 scoring) tailored specifically to your prompt.

Final product:

·       You will have a prompt page that contextualizes the topic and contains the synthesizing prompt.

·       You will have five to six sources—one source per page.

·       You will create an AP-style rubric (scored on 1-9 scale) for your prompt.

·       Attached as an appendix, you will submit a pro, con, objective source write-ups (one per source).

Once you have completed the your prompt and supporting materials, you will write and in-class essay in response to your prompt.  

Bell  Schedule  for Thursday,  March 2, 2017

South Campus                                          Period                                     North Campus

7:45 – 9:07                                                           1                                  7:45 – 8:26 

7:45 Arrive to class,

                       take attendance,

                       drop-off book bags

                7:48  Proceed to field house

               7:58 Recognition Assembly

                8:18 Return to 1^st Period class

                8:28 – 9:07  Conduct 1^st Period class

9:13 – 9:54                                                           2                                          8:32 – 9:14 

10:00 – 10:41                                                      3                                           9:20 – 10:01 

10:47 – 11:12  (25 min.)                                  4a                                       10:07 – 10:32 (25 min.)

11:17 – 11:42  (25 min.)                                  4b                                     10:37 – 11:02 (25 min.)

11:48 – 12:13  (25 min.)                                   5a                                        11:08 – 11:33 (25 min.)

12:18 – 12:43  (25 min.)                                  5b                                              11:38 – 12:03 (25 min.)

12:49 – 1:30                                                        6                                        12:09 – 12:50 

1:36 – 2:17                                                           7                                      12:56-1:37 

2:23 – 3:05                                                           8                                      1:43 – 3:05 

1:43  Arrive to class,  take attendance, drop-off book bags

1:46  Proceed to the FH

1:56  Recognition Assembly

2:16  Return to 8^th period

2:26 – 3:05  Conduct 8^th period class