Friday, September 29, 2017

Overview of an LT student essay

Peer Review 

Read the handout: Sentence Structure - Advice for Improving Sentence Clarity and Tips to Cut the Clutter in Writing. Could any of these strategies help reduce clutter and improve the clarity and flow of your writing?  Read your paper again, and see if there are places where you might improve the clarity.

HW: Make edits/improvements to today's paper, and bring a next-to-final draft on Monday (5 points).  We will do one more peer review, and the final paper will be due on Tuesday, October 3.

Tips to Cut the Clutter in Writing


"Clutter is the disease of American writing," says William Zinsser in his classic text On Writing Well. "We are a society strangling in unnecessary words, circular constructions, pompous frills, and meaningless jargon."
We can cure the disease of clutter (at least in our own compositions) by following a simple rule: don't waste words. When revising and editing, we should aim to cut out any language that is vague, repetitious, or pretentious.
In other words, clear out the deadwood, be concise, and get to the point!
01
of 05

Reduce Long Clauses

getty_clutter-imsis133-011.jpg
(Image Source/Getty Images)
When editing, try to reduce long clauses to shorter phrases:
Wordy: The clown who was in the center ring was riding a tricycle.
Revised: The clown in the center ringwas riding a tricycle.
More About Clauses:
02
of 05

Reduce Phrases

Likewise, try to reduce phrases to single words:
Wordy: The clown at the end of the line tried to sweep up the spotlight.
Revised: The last clown tried to sweep up the spotlight.
More About Phrases:
03
of 05

Avoid Empty Openers

Avoid There isThere are, and There were as sentence openers when There adds nothing to the meaning of a sentence:
WordyThere is a prize in every box of Quacko cereal.
Revised: A prize is in every box of Quacko cereal.
WordyThere are two security guards at the gate.
Revised: Two security guards stand at the gate.
More About Empty Openers:
04
of 05

Don't Overwork Modifiers

Do not overwork veryreallytotally, and other modifiers that add little or nothing to the meaning of a sentence.
Wordy: By the time she got home, Merdine was very tired.
Revised: By the time she got home, Merdine was exhausted
Wordy: She was also really hungry.
Revised: She was also hungry [or famished].
More About Modifiers:
05
of 05

Avoid Redundancies

Replace redundant expressions (phrases that use more words than necessary to make a point) with precise words. Check out this list of common redundancies, and remember: needless words are those that add nothing (or nothing significant) to the meaning of our writing. They bore the reader and distract from our ideas. So cut them out!
WordyAt this point in time, we should edit our work.
RevisedNow we should edit our work.
More About Needless Words:

Hungry for more ways to cut clutter?  Here are five more ways to do that:


"I believe more in the scissors than I do in the pencil," Truman Capote once said. In other words, what we cut out of our writing is sometimes more important than what we put in. So let's continue to cut the clutter.
How do we stop wasting words and get to the point? Here are five more strategies to apply when revising and editing essays, memos, and reports.

1) USE ACTIVE VERBS

Whenever possible, make the subject of a sentence do something.
Wordy: The grant proposals were reviewed by the students.
Revised: The students reviewed the grant proposals.

2) DON'T TRY TO SHOW OFF

As Leonardo da Vinci observed, "Simplicity is the ultimate sophistication." Don't presume that big words or lengthy phrases will impress your readers: often the simplest word is the best.
WordyAt this moment in time, students who are matriculating through high school should be empowered to participate in the voting process.
Revised: High school students should have the right to vote.

3) CUT EMPTY PHRASES

Some of the most common phrases mean little, if anything, and should be cut from our writing:
  • all things being equal
  • all things considered
  • as a matter of fact
  • as far as I am concerned
  • at the end of the day
  • at the present time
  • due to the fact that
  • for all intents and purposes
  • for the most part
  • for the purpose of
  • in a manner of speaking
  • in my opinion
  • in the event of
  • in the final analysis
  • it seems that
  • the point that I am trying to make
  • type of
  • what I am trying to say
  • what I want to make clear
WordyAll things being equalwhat I am trying to say is that in my opinion all students should, in the final analysis, have the right to vote for all intents and purposes.
Revised: Students should have the right to vote.

4) AVOID USING NOUN FORMS OF VERBS

The fancy name for this process is "excessive nominalization." Our advice is simple: give verbs a chance.
Wordy: The presentation of the arguments by the students was convincing.
Revised: The students presented their arguments convincingly. Or . . .
The students argued convincingly.

5) REPLACE VAGUE NOUNS

Replace vague nouns (such as area, aspect, case, factor, manner, situation, something, thing, type, and way) with more specific words--or eliminate them altogether.
Wordy: After reading several things in the area of psychology-type subjects, I decided to put myself in a situation where I might change my major.
Revised: After reading several psychology books, I decided to change my major.

Thursday, September 28, 2017

Thinking and Writing About Literature by Edgar V. Roberts

Today, we will read and discuss part of a chapter Thinking and Writing About Literature by Edgar V. Roberts. In this chapter, he discusses writing essays about ideas in a literary work, which is the thrust of all of  The Scarlet Letter prompts you have; basically, what are some of the ideas Hawthorne is exploring, suggesting, promoting through this novel?

We will start with the first full paragraph on page 92, and read through his discussion of how one might organize a paper; in the process, he will discuss the typical areas of focus, the purpose of each section of an academic essay: intro, body, and conclusions.

Note that Roberts uses the word "theme" as a synonym for "essay". This was common in the past, although it is rarely used in that way today. 

As we read, I want you to record ideas - either on your essay or a piece of paper - that you think might help you examine and improve your essay.  This is intended to be an active reading.  I will ask for thoughts, comments and questions after each paragraph.

Next, we will walk through one example essay. Its subject is D.H. Lawrence's "The Horse Dealers Daughter" and it argues that the text's main idea is that the destiny of humans is to love.

It does not matter that you probably have not read this piece.  The example essay provides enough background to help you understand the work and the ideas in the essay.

Note: This is not a prescriptive example. I am not saying that you must write and structure your essay in this way. But it is an example to help us talk about how an essay develops a thesis.

Now, read through your essay, and make notes and additions to how you will improve your essay tonight.  

HW: Bring 2 copies of your revised draft for tomorrow (5 points)


Tuesday, September 26, 2017

Scarlet Letter Essay Outline & Open, closed, & counterargument thesis statements

First 25 mins...

By tomorrow you must have a working thesis and outline for a full essay.  (5 points - visual check) 
It may be handwritten or typed, but it must be legible.

At the top of the page, above your actual outline, please clearly identify which prompt you are responding to (provide the # and the first sentence of the prompt).

Your outline should address the thesis and at least three body paragraphs

I. Thesis

II.  Topic Sentence
a. relevant textual evidence
b.relevant textual evidence
c. a brief discussion of what you plan to discuss/explore/demonstrate in this paragraph and how it supports your thesis argument. 

III. (same as paragraph II)

IV.  (same as paragraphs II & III)

Monday, September 25, 2017

Scarlet Letter Essay

Review Scarlet Letter Essay Assignment 


The Scarlet Letter Culminating Paper
Wesley 2017
September 25, 2017
Traditional Closed-Thesis Guided Academic Essay
Choose one of the following prompts and reply to it with approximately a 3-4 page paper (double-spaced, 12 point Times New Roman font). Follow MLA format.  The following are seed ideas…they are intentionally open-ended, and the prompts are designed to do just that: prompt you to explore a compelling central idea for a paper.  It is not necessary that you answer every question present in a particular prompt, rather you should use the questions as spring-boards to identifying and developing a compelling controlling idea to guide your paper.
Points: 100
September 26, 2017: have a prompt chosen for paper
September 27, 2017: have a working thesis and outline of major points
September 28, 2017: first draft due/peer review or self-edit
September 29, 2017: second draft due/peer review
October 2, 2017: Final draft due

Traditional Thesis-guided Academic Essay:  There are a lot of ways to write about literature. Some are creative, emotional, highly personal; others are more objective, designed to demonstrate both an insightful comprehension of the text and/or a learned awareness of how literary or rhetorical elements work in general and that text in particular.  The more objective paper is often used in school literature classes and its thesis-driven (usually at the end of the first paragraph), five or six paragraph structure is also popular with other disciplines (eg., history, psychology, economics).  It’s not the only way to write a paper, and some people consider it to be staid, formulaic, and antithetical to creative thinking, but it is a form you should at least be familiar with, and it allows some students to focus on sharing their insights without having to worry unduly about organization (because the organization is already prescribed). Note that I’m not endorsing this approach over others, but it’s one approach that you probably should know, and it can be modified or abandoned when you (or your teacher/professor) want to organize your thoughts in a less prescriptive, more organic way.  For this purposes of this paper, I want you to write a closed thesis sentence unless you can provide me with a compelling reason for an open thesis for your paper.

Between three and six direct quotes per paper.
1.      What role does Chillingworth play for Hawthorne in the novel? How does Hawthorne use him, and why does he matter? Outside connection to possibly consider…Does Hawthorne’s use of Chillingworth as an antagonist or villain mirror that of any other authors/filmmaker’s use of villains? This should not be central to your paper, but might be interesting to touch upon in the opening/and or closing paragraphs. A warning, however; don’t force it! Trying to do too much in an essay and wedging in a connection in a superficial or clumsy way, can ruin an essay.

2.      Pearl can be confounding, but the novel wouldn’t be nearly as interesting without her.  To what ends does Hawthorne use this complex character in the novel? How does Hawthorne use her to develop certain ideas and/or messages?    




3.      Could The Scarlet Letter be considered a feminist novel? Although Hawthorne was a man writing before the advent of the modern feminist movement and the novel is set in the Puritan past, certain characters and themes have prompted some modern readers to ask whether or not The Scarlet Letter could be considered a feminist novel.  Make an argument that supports, refutes or qualifies the idea that The Scarlet Letter is a feminist novel. Make sure you provide a working definition of feminism and a feminist novel.  Outside connection to consider: It might be interesting if you can make a meaningful (not forced or perfunctory) connection to the recent Lion focus on feminism, and/or identify anything that the novel might offer to current discussions of gender roles (regardless of whether or not you classify it as a feminist novel).

4.      What is the significance of Nature (Mother Nature) in The Scarlet Letter? How does Nature help drive the plot and themes? 

5.      What ideas about mental and/or spiritual sickness and health might Hawthorne be exploring through The Scarlet Letter? Many characters (and perhaps whole communities) in the novel possess spiritual and/or psychological traits which the modern reader (and perhaps Hawthorne) might view as extreme or unhealthy, whereas other characters might be deemed more psychologically healthy or spiritually enlightened. Furthermore, some characters undergo some form or spiritual and psychological changes in the novel.  In summary, what does Hawthorne seem to be suggesting about healthy and unhealthy spirituality and psychology? Note: Don’t try to address every spiritual or psychological issue that might be addressed by Hawthorne; pick one or two to focus on. 

6.      To many readers, Dimmesdale is a figure of hypocrisy who preaches virtue from the pulpit and refuses to take his daughter’s hand in public, but pays a terrible personal price for his actions. Others see him as a tragic, but typically flawed, human and see elements of redemption in his final acts.  How do you think Hawthorne wants the reader to see Dimmesdale? Does he want our impression of Dimmesdale to change throughout the course of the novel?   What should we make of the different ways that the townsfolk remembered his final moments?

7.      What points, if any, do you think Hawthorne is trying to make about organized religion? Does Hawthorne suggest or imply any reforms, or does he simply offer a critique? What critiques and/or suggestions for change does he seem to be offering? 



8.      Something else…If you have another idea for a great paper – perhaps related to one of your turnitin.com question posts – you can propose that to me. It must be a truly meaningful idea for you, not something that is simply easier than the other options above or based on a cliché’ topic from some online source.  Approval by me is required.

Friday, September 22, 2017

Lion Time (15 mins)

Scarlet Letter Reflection

"Roger Chillingworth was a striking evidence of man’s faculty of transforming himself into a devil." What role does Chillingworth play? Do you think he is morally more degenerate than Hester and her lover, or do you have sympathy for his campaign of revenge? Do you think he redeems himself at all with his bequest to Pearl at the end of the story? Why do you think Hawthorne wrote those actions towards Pearl into the ending of the story? 

Is The Scarlet Letter a feminist novel?

What is the significance of Nature (Mother Nature) in The Scarlet Letter? How does Nature drive the plot and theme?

What do you make of Pearl? Although she at first appears to be a secondary character in the novel, Pearl figures significantly into many of the novel’s key narrative events. What is Pearl’s significance in the novel as a whole?

On page 178, Hawthorne remarks on the root similarities between hate and love.  Do you agree with him? How might this change your view of the story?

What does The Scarlet Letter teach us about mental and spiritual health?  Many characters (and perhaps whole communities)  in the novel possess spiritual and psychological traits which the modern reader (and perhaps Hawthorne) might view as extreme or unhealthy; some characters might be deemed more psychologically healthy or spiritually enlightened.  Or is it as simple as this character is healthy while this one is not? How does Hawthorne make it more complex? In summary, what does Hawthorne seem to be suggesting about healthy and unhealthy spirituality and psychology?

Dimmesdale is a figure of hypocrisy who preaches virtue from the pulpit and refuses to take his daughter’s hand in public, but pays a terrible personal price for his actions. Others see elements of redemption in his final acts. What points do you think Hawthorne is trying to make about organized religion? Does the book suggest or hint at reforms, or simply offer a critique?

The Scarlet Letter draws heavily on religious images, symbols, and allusions. One common character type in Western literature is the Christ-type.  Using evidence from How to Read Like a Professor and The Scarlet Letter, make an argument for how one of the characters in The Scarlet Letter functions as a Christ-type and how Hawthorne uses the Christ-type elements of that character to develop and convey a particular theme or message.


Pearl can be confounding.  Is she a force for good or evil, how does Hawthorne use her to develop a theme or message?  



No homework

On Monday we will talk about specific writing options for The Scarlet Letter 

Thursday, September 21, 2017

Scarlet Letter ch 21-24




(12 minutes) Respond to 1)  the question below and 2) another question posted on turnitin.com which you found intriguing but which you did not already respond to online last night. Most of you response should be in your own words, representing an organic response to the question, but also embed in your response a small quote that is in some way germane to your thinking on the matter.


ger·mane


adj.
Related to a matter at hand, especially to a subject under discussion

1) On page 175, as Pearl kisses Dimmsdale on the scaffold, she starts crying and her tears "were a pledge that she would grow up amid human joy and sorrow." After so many instances of the other characters calling Pearl a demon or comparing her to satan, why is this sudden emotion displayed? What was Hawthorne's purpose in connecting Pearl to sympathy and perhaps even love? What does it have to do with how she will go forward in life, and how she used to act? What is the significance of her crying over Dimmsdale?

2) respond to a classmate's question

No homework